Chelsea punisment extremely lenient - ex-Blues executive Purslow

Christian Purslow spent five years as Aston Villa chief executive officer after his time at Chelsea Former Chelsea senior executive Christian Purslow believes the Premier League has been "way too generous" in its punishment of the club for making secret payments relating to transfers. Chelsea were fined £10m and handed a suspended transfer ban after admitting making £47.5m in undisclosed payments to unregistered agents and third-parties between 2011 and 2018. The fine is the largest ever imposed by the Premier League but the club avoided any sporting sanctions, such as a points deduction. "I think this is the most serious thing to break in the Premier League for a long time," Purslow said on The Football Boardroom , external podcast. Purslow, a former managing director of Liverpool and Aston Villa chief executive, added: "I think the vast majority of people in the game... will view this as an extremely lenient and favourable outcome for Chelsea Football Club. "The level of mitigation that has been applied here is way too generous, and in my opinion very inconsistent with previous regulatory cases and sanctions." Purslow was head of commercial activities at Chelsea between 2014 and 2017, but insisted he had "nothing to do with the playing side". He added he was "shocked to see the scale of activity", and had never encountered any evidence of transfer-related payments during his career. Chelsea's cheating - was a fine too lenient? How Chelsea signed a star team with hidden payments How Chelsea signed a star team with hidden payments Everton and Nottingham Forest received points deductions for breaking Premier League Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) in recent years but despite making "obvious and deliberate breaches" which "involved deception and concealment in relation to financial matters", Chelsea were spared a sporting sanction. When the punishment was announced Chelsea said: "From the outset of this process, the club has treated these matters with the utmost seriousness, providing full cooperation to all relevant regulators." Because the breaches came during former owner Roman Abramovich's time in charge, and new owners BlueCo made voluntary disclosures and showed "exceptional co-operation", that was viewed as enough mitigation to avoid more severe punishment. "This is essentially a litany of offences related to how you conduct transfer business, so a transfer ban makes sense," Purslow said. "But to see that ban suspended in full, again, seems extremely lenient. "That must really rankle with clubs like Everton and Forest who I don't think have had much credit in the past where they have co-operated." The Premier League has previously stated, when handing Everton a points deduction, that "a financial penalty for a club that enjoys the support of a wealthy owner is not a sufficient penalty". That verdict also stated "the requirements of deterrence, vindication of compliant clubs, and the protection of the integrity of the sport demand a sporting sanction in the form of a points deduction". Chelsea signed players such as Eden Hazard, Samuel Eto'o, Willian, Ramires, David Luiz and Nemanja Matic as they won seven majors honours between 2011 and 2018, including two Premier League titles and the Champions League. "Sporting sanctions first came into the frame as an acknowledgement that sometimes punishing with a fine just didn't fit the crime," Purslow added. "In other words, when football clubs had gained meaningful football advantage, you needed to sanction with sporting penalty to compensate. "It is blindingly obvious that sporting benefits were attained through this transfer activity." Sports law barrister Nick de Marco KC represented Leicester and Forest in their PSR cases. He wrote on X: "When it is argued, in various football disputes, that points deductions must be imposed even for inadvertent breaches, in order to vindicate compliant clubs, one has to wonder whether that reflects a genuine commitment to consistent strict enforcement in all cases, or is simply a position adopted for the purposes of a particular case. "Consistency is very important in sport - the lack of it can undermine public confidence in the integrity of the whole game." Latest Chelsea news, analysis and fan views Ask about Chelsea - what do you want to know? Champions League: Build-up to Barcelona v Newcastle before Liverpool & Tottenham play Senegal government alleges corruption over Afcon 'The longest VAR check in history' - the fallout from shock Afcon decision Don’t miss Red Nose Day, live from 7pm on Friday 20 March Have Chelsea silenced the critics? Inside the hidden world of China’s ‘mistress dispellers’ What happens when motherhood is pushed to its limits? Afcon final chaos - key questions answered Why ex-Palace winger Olise is now in Ballon d'Or contention at Bayern Have Liverpool lost 'chaotic' edge that made them so feared? The 'anti-Lamine' backed to be one of best in world Will Champions League be Guardiola's Man City regret? 'Being in Manchester has made me love nature so much more' Video 'Being in Manchester has made me love nature so much more' Inside the state school at the top of English rugby union 'Looking like the Hamilton of old' and potential rule changes - F1 Q&A Chelsea's cheating - was a fine too lenient? 'Haaland of rugby' - how Bielle-Biarrey has stormed stage Who makes BBC pundits' Six Nations team of the tournament? Video Who makes BBC pundits' Six Nations team of the tournament? Another compelling Players - but why is it unlikely to ever be a major? Norrie replaces Draper as British number one - but for how long? Aberg & Fitzpatrick falter as Young becomes Players champion. Video Aberg & Fitzpatrick falter as Young becomes Players champion Have Old Firm wrestled title momentum away from Hearts? Copyright © 2026 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.